📰 The two controversial calls against star winger that cost Warriors the game
- Publish date
- Monday, 6 May 2024, 8:27AM
Sunday’s third straight loss for the New Zealand Warriors was not without drama.
Two crucial calls went against the side in their 14-8 defeat to the Newcastle Knights, the worst being a crucial penalty try that would have given them a half-time lead.
After a hapless opening 20 minutes where they gave away five penalties, made four errors and handed Newcastle an 8-0 lead, the Warriors got the game back to 8-6.
Winger Dallin Watene-Zelezniak then appeared to hand the Warriors the lead, only for him to drop a ball over the line while being tackled in mid-air by Greg Marzhew.
“Our game throws up some doozies sometimes and this is clearly one of them,” commentator Michael Ennis said.
“He’s tackled in the air and it’s not a penalty try. If he catches it, he scores no problem. Not sure how it’s not a penalty try.”
Shaun Johnson argued with referee Chris Butler that a penalty try should have been awarded, given Watene-Zelezniak seemed certain to score without the contact.
Butler agreed, but told Johnson it was against NRL interpretations for penalty tries to be given when players are tackled mid-air.
“The only reason he didn’t score is because he got tackled in the air,” Warriors coach Andrew Webster said after the game.
“I don’t understand if there’s a clause for that particular play if you’re attacking and tackled in the air, but it looked like he was deadset going to score for all money.
“I thought a penalty try is if someone is about to score, and they’re not allowed to through a penalty.”
The Warriors were then denied again after the break, Jackson Ford ruled to have obstructed Jackson Hastings in the lead up to a Watene-Zelezniak touchdown.
There is no way that wasn't a penalty try with DWZ tackled in mid air. If it's not, there is no point having the rule.
— Michael Burgess (@mikeburgess99) May 5, 2024
DWZ doesn't drop the ball if he is not tackled. Very poor from the bunker, who seemed in a rush when there was no reason to be. @NZWarriors @nzheraldsport
Penalty try every day of the week ending in Y, Butler and the bunker official will have questions to answer on Monday pic.twitter.com/FrP0sHiMnI
— Josh (@Bearded_J_NZ) May 5, 2024
Tackled before catching the ball in the air put in a dangerous position. Warriors = penalty only panthers, Melbourne, Roosters = penalty try and sin bin #NRL #CORRUPTION #NRLKnightsWarriors
— Hira (@SharpEdgeNZ) May 5, 2024
So tackling someone in the air, who has taken clean possession of the ball and is looking to put the ball down. Is not a penalty try, or a sin bin? “We never give penalty tries for that”… why not?? #NRLKnightsWarriors
— Joshua Hill (@Kiinghill) May 5, 2024
That’s a very, VERY contentious call on half-time…
— Jack Blyth (@jblesfooty224) May 5, 2024
A penalty try all day for mine to DWZ.
He catches it cleanly, is tackled in mid-air (which is penalised) and causes him to drop it as he goes to put the ball down.
No other Knights player within cooee.#NRLKnightsWarriors
This article was first published on nzherald.co.nz and is republished here with permission
Take your Radio, Podcasts and Music with you